Worthy.com Review
Why you should not sell your diamonds or gold jewelry with Worthy
 | |||||
Overall Score:3 | | ||||
Price:2.5 | | Selection:3 | | Customer Service: 3.5 | |
| Pros |
| ||||
| Cons |
| ||||
| Other Recommended Retailers |
A Look at Worthy
Worthy is an interesting company with a hybrid business model. Before they came around, there were two options for selling your diamond. You can go the direct-to-consumer route via sites like eBay or you can go the local route (retailer, pawn shop etc) that will purchase the diamond.
There are fundamental flaws with both of these business models. We explain why eBay is a terrible business model for diamonds in our review. Going the traditional route of finding a diamond dealer and selling it to them is fine. The problem is finding the right diamond dealer. For people who find our site, we’ve done that research and testing for you.
As you can see from our test of online diamond and jewelry buyers, there was a wide range of values offered depending on who you went to. If you are searching on your own and find one of the dealers that low-balls every offer, you are flat out of luck.
Worthy’s unique approach is to take your diamond ring and auction it to many diamond dealers, wholesalers and retailers. This way you get the highest bid from all of them instead of having to go to each of them, one at a time.
The question that remains is whether Worthy’s approach results with you ending up getting more money for your diamond. In this article we break down why Worthy’s business model does not offer the best value for you when trying to sell your diamond.
Why you should trust us
To help you with the diamond buying process we lean on our expertise and experience. The author of this article, our CEO, Mike Fried has over 20 years of experience in the diamond industry. Mike started from the bottom, sorting and evaluating hundreds of thousands of diamonds to learn every facet (pun intended) of diamond quality and value. Mike followed that up by spending years buying and selling diamonds on the wholesale market as well as selling tens of millions of dollars worth of diamonds to diamond retailers.
Here’s what we’ll cover in this article:
Worthy: Fundamentally flawed business model
How Worthy works
How much are the fees at Worthy?
We tested Worthy
Worthy vs. Abe Mor
Bottom line recommendation
Fundamentally Flawed Business Model
Auctioning jewelry is nothing new — in fact, it’s a well-established approach for selling diamond rings and other pieces of jewelry. The GIA even lists auctioning your item as a worthwhile approach in its guide to selling gemstones and jewelry:
“You could try selling your gemstones or jewelry through a local auction house or through an online auction site. If a gemstone or piece of jewelry is of high quality, you might consider selling it through one of the larger auction houses.” Gemological Institute of America (GIA)
While this sounds nice in theory, in the case of Worthy, there is one “minor” problem with this model that seems to get left out of the discussion.
Worthy needs to make money on your diamond as well.
As we explain in our “Selling Your Diamond” article, you are already behind the eight ball when trying to unload your ring. There is no way you will get back as much money as you think.
By going through Worthy you may be increasing your exposure when trying to sell your ring, but any gains in the offer are offset by the fee Worthy charges for being the middle-man. For the majority of people, the fee that worthy charges is 20%.
Keep in mind that the people bidding from Worthy are industry insiders and experienced at purchasing diamonds. It’s not like there is going to be one person looking at their screen saying “screw it, I’ll pay 50% more than anyone else is bidding” and make your day.
Deal Alert: Get 25% off sitewide at James Allen
How Worthy.com Works
How does Worthy work? You head over to Worthy’s site, put in basic information (type of ring, diamond etc) and they give you an estimated range of bids you would receive. If you decide to proceed, they send you a shipping label and you send them your jewelry.
The forms are clear and easy to use. There are clear filters that you put in your information on. There are two sections, one for diamond engagement rings and for other jewelry.
If you are looking to sell your diamond engagement ring, they ask you basic questions about the size, color, clarity and source of the ring. If you are looking to sell other types of jewelry they don’t ask for much more info (which makes sense as there is no way to narrow down all the thousands of types of jewelry into an easy to use filter).
Worthy.com Fees
Worthy does an excellent job of burying their fees. If you look at last section of the “how it works” section, you will find the fee schedule. It looks like the overwhelming majority of their customers pay between 14 and 22% at the time of this update.
I should also point out that in every conversation and email I had with Worthy, they did not mention their fees. Whenever they would quote their estimates (of how much the ring would go for in auction) they would quote the sale price, not how much I would actually receive. It wasn’t until I specifically asked that I was told how much they would take off the top.
How Long is the Worthy.com Process
It can be difficult to know just how long the process will take as it varies depending on what type of jewelry you are selling. For us, the process took two and a half weeks (not including the discussions I had prior to sending the ring).
Worthy.com Pros
- Excellent website. Very thorough and easy to use interface.
- Auction style allows you to reach multiple buyers at one time.
Worthy.com Cons
- Long and convoluted process.
- Worthy’s fees make it unlikely you will end up getting the best deal.
Certification/Appraisal
This is the biggest bonus working with Worthy. Every ring they auction off will have a GIA or IGI certificate. If your ring doesn’t have one currently, they will send it to the lab at no cost to you (I don’t know how they operate, I’d imagine that they will reject some items as it’s not worth the money to certify them). This is very useful as local appraisals don’t really tell you what the quality is.
The Test
Getting Things Started
So we were looking to sell a Tiffany ring that we had purchased for our updated review. It was a 0.53ct I color, VVS2 clarity round diamond in the classic Tiffany platinum solitaire setting. We purchased the ring for $4,500 (yes, we know that’s overpriced).
After filling out their form, I started a conversation with someone at Worthy. At that point, I already had the offer (pending inspection) from Abe Mor for $1,850. The estimate that popped was only $1,100ish.
I mentioned that I had a significantly higher bid and didn’t want to waste their time (and mine) if they didn’t have a chance of beating that bid. Due to their commission, they would need to get a bid over $2,100 to beat my current offer.
The sales rep for Worthy said they would reach out to some of the bidders (companies that usually purchase Tiffany rings and are willing to pay a premium). A couple of days later he got back to me saying he thought there was a good chance to make that number.
I sent them the ring. A few days later, the ring was ready for auction. Unfortunately, the bids were far more inline with their initial estimate. The final bid was $1,458. After their 20% fee (they have since adjusted their fees as we mention above), the final amount I would receive was $1,165.
I was kind of disappointed that the sales rep pushed hard for me to send it in (despite not getting any bids remotely close to what I told him I needed). Maybe he didn’t believe me when I said I had another offer, or maybe some of the people he spoke to didn’t bid near what they said they would. But it did feel like a waste of time to me.
Worthy vs. Abe Mor
If you’ve been around our site you may know that the company we recommend to help you sell your jewelry is Abe Mor. Hundreds of our readers have reached out to Abe Mor and successfully sold their diamond rings and reported back to us that they had a fantastic experience. If you are interested in a more thorough comparison, you can read this article.
Bottom Line Recommendation:
While Worthy certainly has an interesting way of doing business, it is not in your best interests to try and sell your diamond or gold jewelry through worthy.com. Their business model adds way too much in fees for you to end up getting maximum value for your jewelry.
After extensive secret testing, the results bore that out. We were offered 50% more by Abe Mor for the same piece of jewelry.
Having trouble navigating the diamond and jewelry selling minefield? We are happy to help. CONTACT US
Still afraid of getting ripped off?
Before you buy a diamond, get personal buying advice from industry veterans. We'll help you get the best diamond for the money.
Ask your diamond purchase question here
DISCLAIMER: We don't use your email for marketing. Period.
You Might Like
Diamond Prices: A Complete Guide
A diamonds’ price is determined primarily by the 4 Cs of the diamond. On the wholesale level, diamond prices are first based on a diamond shape and
The Best Places to Buy Engagement Rings
When purchasing a diamond engagement ring, it’s important to find the right retailer to purchase it from. Some retailers excel at niche products li
1 Carat Diamond Price & Buying Guide
A wide range of 1 carat diamonds exist both in online markets and local diamond jewelry stores. Not only are there significant differences in beauty
